Shouldn't PSC be following A*STAR's example?

I find the proportion of PSC scholars from well-to-do families at 53% alarming, compared to A*STAR with a majority of over 70% from HDB homes (Figures as quoted by Mr Philip Yeo).

April 5, 2006
Profile of govt scholarship holders
By Leslie Koh

STUDENTS from better-off families made up about half of government scholarship holders last year. Around one out of two came from families that earn more than $5,000 and live in private homes.

Figures from the Prime Minister's Office show that 53 per cent of Public Service Commission (PSC) scholarship holders came from families earning at least $5,000. This places them in the top one-third of families by income as only 37 per cent of all families in Singapore earned $5,000 or more in 2004.

PM Lee Hsien Loong also said 47 per cent of PSC scholarship holders live in private homes, putting them among the 15 per cent of all families here that can afford more expensive private housing.He gave these figures in a written reply to Nominated MP Tan Sze Wee in Parliament on Monday.

These figures are likely to fuel concerns that poorer families find it harder to move up the social ladder, as students from poorer homes have a lower chance of getting sought-after government scholarships that often pave the way for a good career in the civil service.In a column last year, recent graduate Soon Sze Meng asked if social mobility is on the decline here.Wealthier and better-educated parents can send their children to better schools, he noted, and they will, in turn, do better and win scholarships.

Sociologist Alexius Pereira of the National University of Singapore took a different view of the numbers, saying they give little cause for worry.It is common across the world for the highly educated to make it into the top social class, he noted. In the United States, students from richer families dominate the newcomer list at top Ivy League universities every year.'At these universities, only 5 per cent are from underprivileged families. In Singapore, half of scholarship holders come from average-income families. That's okay,' he said.

The PSC, which gives out about 50 scholarships each year, stressed that it awards them based on students' abilities and potential, not on their socio-economic background.'PSC scholarships are not study loans or bursaries which are granted based on financial need,' said the director of the PSC secretariat, Mrs Choo Lee See.The statistics appear not to have changed much over the past few years.At a scholarship award ceremony in 2000, PM Lee said 49 per cent of the 110 recipients that day had at least one parent who was a professional or manager. He also stressed then that restricting scholarships to poorer students is not in line with Singapore's principles of meritocracy and equal opportunity.

Dr Pereira also noted that Singapore's meritocratic system ensures that bright but poor students do not miss out.'If you're stupid and rich, you can't buy yourself out of it. But if you're bright but underprivileged, there are enough safeguards to ensure you can still make it.'

I like to believe that tax payers would like to see their monies being used to help those, who truly deserve it. I am referring to poorer, but academically bright students. I have a viable solution that may well work. Award the sum of monies that the scholarship contract is worth inversely proportional to the income of the family. Thus, if a scholar comes from a very rich family, the amount of monies awarded to his scholarship is less or even nil (in the case of a scholar hailing from a family of millionaires) , i.e. a scholar in name. At the end of the spectrum, the poor student should be awarded more monies for his tuitions fees, living expenses and air tickets. I figure this is a more egalitarian way of doing things.

Furthermore, instead of giving out the full sum of monies to the 53% of the scholars from well-to-do families, we can set aside the sum saved and even open up more places for scholarship to poorer students. Before long, PSC would be giving out scholarships to more than 70% of applicants from poorer families living in the HDB heartlands.